For the ninth year, SSAT has celebrated and shared outstanding practice from schools across the country in the Achievement Show – this year, back at the site of the original show, the Emirates Stadium, North London.
Leaders and teachers from over 50 schools gave presentations of no longer than 45 minutes, highlighting their challenges and successes. Most importantly, the speakers gave the detail, and advice on what worked and what didn’t, and why.
The presentations covered a wide range of subjects and approaches: there was something there for everyone. Over the next week, we are publishing on our blog reports from a small selection, covering mobile technology in and outside the classroom, motivating disparate categories of students, retaining learning, school radio stations, special needs education, and oracy in young people from severely deprived backgrounds.
We began with Greg Hughes’ session on the impact of learning technologies at de Ferrers Academy. A second report gave you four advantages of investing in mobile technology. Our third piece recalled how a north London school has tackled severe language deprivation. A fourth report contained advice from a special school for mainstream schools on supporting students with autism. The fifth summary covered the age-old challenge of unengaged boys. This penultimate report gives you three ways of enhancing knowledge retention…
Colin Sisson, associate assistant principal, and Dave Taylor, vice-principal, Bluecoat Beechdale Academy, Bluecoat Academies Trust, addressed the question: how do you ensure learning stays beyond the exam?
They maintain the answer comes down to three key factors a lesson should include:
- Action: movement or performance
- Emotion: exploring, emphasising or provoking emotional states
- Narrative: connected events, distinct from the normal classroom experience.
They and colleagues asked a large number of students in different age groups when they could recall a key learning point, and what happened in the lesson that triggered it.
Some of the differences between groups were fascinating. Boys predominantly recalled learning points related to action, very rarely narrative; whereas girls recalled points related to all three factors.
There were age differences, too. Students in year 8, in classes with wide ranges of abilities, responded to all three triggers, predominantly action. Those in year 10 responded mainly to action and emotion. Those in year 11 responded mainly to action triggers.
Action was an effective learning trigger for all groups of students, from reading ages of five to 17+. It was most effective with children with special needs or English as an additional language.
Emotion was recognised as a factor predominantly by girls; some boys also saw this as a trigger for learning. Eighty-eight percent of students qualifying for pupil premium recognised it as important. Students with ‘robust’ reading ages also tended to recognise it. Colin Sisson commented: “Emotion captures adolescents’ attention: they want new experiences and sensations.”
Narrative received positive responses from all of the girls surveyed, most noticeably those with reading ages of 10-17+. Such narratives included dramatic situations, fictional roles, views of one’s own and others’ behaviour from unfamiliar perspectives. Boys were less responsive.
Action was a most effective learning trigger for students with SEN or EAL;
Emotion was recognised as important by 88% of PP students
Connections help learning retention
The presenters conclude that the more you connect learning to other things, the more likely it is that you will retain it. To some extent it’s about being part of a large story: ‘mutual clues’ enable you to retrieve the information later. Further, it enables us to expand our ability to take action and be effective in the world.
Turning these findings into action in class, Colin Sisson now ensures that action (by students, rather than the teacher) plays a large part in lessons, even or perhaps especially revision sessions. For example, in revision for GCSE English, he set up ‘character autopsies’: a box on each group’s table containing a plastic skull, covered by a cloth. The teacher appeared in a lab coat. The students’ task was to articulate how a character in a book or play had influenced and been influenced by other characters. The students listed the factors they chose and stuck them on the skulls with Post-Its. Not only did this session score highly in all three – action, emotion and narrative – it also boosted the students’ confidence for the forthcoming exam from a score of 5.5 to 7.1.
Overall, a task containing action, emotion and narrative is most likely to lead to retention
The academy’s radio station has given wider opportunities for all three triggers through participation in the wide range of roles – journalist, editor, marketing and advertising – as students gather, edit, produce and promote the show.
The presenters were keen to reject any thought that they linked their findings with ‘learning styles’ ideas, which they maintained have been dismissed by cognitive scientists. Despite individual groups’ different preferences among the three factors, an excellent lesson, the Bluecoat Beechdale staff have found, includes all three.
Check out photos from the SSAT Achievement Show 2016 on our Facebook page.